@brownb499 said: If Peyton wins it all this year (and that's a big if...but he's getting closer) he will be the only QB to win a super bowl with 2 different teams. Well, Kurt Warner came within seconds of doing that....and Tobin Rote did win Championships with two different teams. Maybe Peyton can aspire to be as good as Tobin Rote? That would put him up there as one of the greatest of all time. OK, get this: He is already up there as one of the greatest of all time. I still do not believe that if he wins that he is by any means clearly the greatest of all time...but he is in the team photo, and it is like a basketball team size roster, not a football team size. Personally Montana would be my greatest ever simply because he never lost...And I'm old enough to have seen Starr,Unitas and Namath play. Montana lost....in earlier rounds. Just like everyone else did. So that is not the main deal. But who one thinks is the GOAT is subjective. And subjectively my gut still puts Joe Cool and Tom Terrific ahead of the count. By the way Gipper,didn't Earl Moral come dam close to winning super bowls with two different teams? I was thinking he played some in the Colts win over Miami...and then led the Dolphins all the way to the playoffs but stepped aside when Griese healed up? Correct. Morral started almost all of the Dolphins game of their undefeated season in 1972. To be honest with you...in my opinion, Bob Griese is probably the most undeserving QB that has made the HOF. In his team's best year, he barely platyed.